In the third quarter of 2026, the median sold price in Augusta County reached $400,525. That is 12.3% higher than in the same quarter of 2025 and the county's third straight quarter of year-over-year gains, according to the Greater Augusta Association of REALTORS® Q3 2026 Housing Market Report. In the same quarter, Staunton's median fell 2.1% to $295,000 and Waynesboro's fell 2.4% to $303,990.
To an owner on Forest Springs Drive the county number sounds like good news, and to someone shopping there it sounds like a warning, but for an established Stuarts Draft neighborhood it is neither one. The 12% describes which homes sold in the county this year. It does not describe what an existing house gained. A Forest Springs resale is priced against the new homes for sale a short drive away, and that comparison tells you more than the county headline.
A Price Jump That Doesn't Behave Like Appreciation
The other Augusta County numbers in the same report show a market that slowed down while its median climbed. In Q3 2026, median days on market rose from 8 to 14. Active listings grew 5.9% to 199, and months of supply rose from 2.7 to 3.2. For January through September 2026, closed sales were 546, down 13.9% from 634 in the same months of 2025. The year-to-date median still rose 12.1%, to $395,000 from $352,500.
So homes took longer to sell, there were more of them to choose from, and fewer sold over nine months. A median rising by double digits in those conditions points to a change in which homes are selling. If more of the homes changing hands are newer and larger, the middle of the price range moves up even when no individual house is worth more than it was a year ago. The report itself names Augusta County as the one area that raised the regional median this quarter.
Here are the three localities side by side for the third quarter of 2026:
| Q3 2026 | Augusta County | Staunton | Waynesboro |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median sold price | $400,525, up 12.3% | $295,000, down 2.1% | $303,990, down 2.4% |
| Closed sales | 196, up 4.8% | 92, down 4.2% | 108, down 4.4% |
| Median days on market | 14, up from 8 | 9, up from 8 | 14, up from 11 |
| Months of supply | 3.2, up from 2.7 | 4.2, up from 2.3 | 3.6, up from 2.3 |
| Avg. sold-to-list ratio | 99.2% | 98.9% | 100.0% |
The Price List on Lookover Terrace
The clearest example of the new-home side of the county market is in Stuarts Draft. Atlantic Builders sells Hills at Overlook, a section of the larger Overlook community. Its sales office is at 15 Lookover Terrace, and visitors reach it from Route 340 by way of White Hill Road. These were the base prices posted in mid-November 2026:
- Marlowe on a slab foundation, 2,470+ square feet: from $379,905
- Kemper, 1,962+ square feet: from $389,900
- Marlowe, 2,470+ square feet: from $394,155
- Wingate, a one-level plan with 2,419+ square feet: from $436,905
The county's $400,525 median falls inside that range. One subdivision's price list doesn't prove what moved the county median. It does show that a brand-new, two-car-garage home in Stuarts Draft sells at the same price that now reads as "typical" for Augusta County. When sales like these make up a bigger share of the county's closings, the median rises toward them.
The builder can also adjust the financing. The same page advertises a "Year End Savings Event," and its sample monthly payment uses an FHA 5/1 adjustable-rate mortgage at a 6.5% initial rate, 7.202% APR, on the $379,905 price. For comparison, the Federal Reserve raised its benchmark rate on September 16, 2026, and the 30-year fixed rate went above 7% in late September, according to Freddie Mac figures summarized in the GAAR September 2026 Monthly Indicators report. Those loan figures are the builder's advertised example as of this month. This post is general information, not financial or legal advice, and any buyer should confirm terms with their own lender. A Forest Springs seller has a different set of tools: list price, condition, and what a 30-year-old lot has that a new one doesn't.
What Forest Springs Has That a New Lot Doesn't
Forest Springs Drive, Route 1530, connects Cold Springs Road, Route 608, to Springer Road. In our own neighborhood guide, we describe Forest Springs as being in southern Stuarts Draft, with mostly ranch, colonial and traditional homes built from the 1980s through the 2000s and a forest conservation easement at the back of the neighborhood that gives many lots wooded backyards. A new lot can't come with trees that took decades to grow.
For a Forest Springs buyer, the county median is the wrong benchmark. A 12% county gain built partly on new construction doesn't mean a 1990s colonial is worth 12% more than its comparable sale from last fall. Recent sales of similar homes close by are the better measure. The base prices at Hills at Overlook set a ceiling the resale has to justify, and the resale's case rests on the mature trees, the woods behind it and an established street.
For a Forest Springs seller, the same reasoning shows where the price has to make sense. A buyer touring a 1980s ranch on a Saturday may well tour a model on Lookover Terrace the same afternoon. If the resale is priced near $400,000 because that's the county median, the buyer will compare it with a new 2,470-square-foot plan sold during the builder's year-end savings event. The countywide numbers also show buyers gaining time to decide: across the GAAR region in Q3 2026, months of supply rose 42% to 3.5, the biggest year-over-year increase in three years, and the median time on market lengthened by three days to 12. Sellers still got close to their asking price, with Augusta County's sold-to-list ratio at 99.2% for the quarter. In practice, homes priced against the right comparables are still selling close to list, and they're doing it against more competition than a year ago.
More New Homes Are Approved Along Route 340
New homes will be a bigger part of the Stuarts Draft comparison over the next few years, not a smaller one. On August 27, 2025, the Augusta County Board of Supervisors approved an 88-acre rezoning for Sunrise Investors, which The News Leader reported is a step toward about 400 new homes in Stuarts Draft. The county's hearing notice puts that land off Stuarts Draft Highway, US-340, and Locust Grove Lane, Route 1476. About 63 acres are planned for single-family homes and about 23 acres for attached homes.
Closer to the center of Stuarts Draft, an 8.9-acre housing project sits between West and East High Street, north of Wayne Avenue. In July 2025, The News Leader reported that the project was moving forward after a supervisors' vote. In Fishersville, supervisors approved a 200-home development in April 2026, according to The News Leader.
None of these approvals is a finished neighborhood. They do mean the county median will probably stay tied to new construction for a while, and a Forest Springs home will be valued by comparison with whatever the builders along Route 340 are offering that season.
Quick Answers
Did existing homes in Augusta County really gain 12% in value? The county figure covers every closed sale in Q3 2026, new and resale together. Days on market rose and year-to-date sales fell 13.9% at the same time, which points to a change in which homes sold more than a 12% gain on existing homes. Recent sales of comparable homes nearby are the better measure for a particular house.
Is new construction in Stuarts Draft priced above Forest Springs? Posted base prices at Hills at Overlook in November 2026 run from $379,905 to $436,905. A Forest Springs resale competes with those figures on the strength of an established lot and the wooded backyards behind many of its homes.
Should Staunton's or Waynesboro's falling medians matter to a Stuarts Draft buyer? They're useful context. In Q3 2026, both cities' medians stayed near $300,000 while months of supply rose sharply, so buyers across the area have more homes to choose from than they did a year ago.
If you're pricing a home in Forest Springs or deciding between a resale and a new build along Route 340, Nest Realty - Shenandoah Valley can pull the recent sales on your street and line them up against current builder pricing, so your decision rests on the homes you're actually choosing between. Read more about the area in our Stuarts Draft neighborhood guide.